| Platinum | Twin Peaks |
| Gold | Mike's Tavern |
| Silver | 1885 Grill |
| Bronze | St. John's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Boathouse Rotisserie & Raw Bar |
| Top Pick | Captain D's Seafood Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Easy Bistro & Bar |
| Top Pick | Pier 88 Boiling Seafood & Bar |
| Top Pick | Red Lobster |
| Top Pick | Uncle Larry's Restaurant |