| Platinum | Cupcake Kitchen |
| Gold | Chatta-Cakes Bakery |
| Silver | Muddy Acres Farm |
| Bronze | Niedlov's Bakery & Cafe |
| Top Pick | Bread and Butter |
| Top Pick | Jackson Bakery |
| Top Pick | Morning Bee Bakery and Bagelry |
| Top Pick | Simply Southern Bakery |
| Top Pick | The Bread Basket |
| Top Pick | The Cultivated Homestead |